Council Opposition to Prop E: Violation of Campaign Finance Law

Oct 25, 2026 | City Council

Earlier this month, many residents were appalled by a City Council resolution that was full of gross misinformation and misstatements of fact regarding Proposal E. Resolution Encouraging Ann Arbor Voters To Vote “No” on Proposal E was placed on the October 5, 2026 agenda of Ann Arbor City Council. It was so factually flawed that it prompted a lengthy fact-check from the Ann Arbor for Public Power organization.

https://annarborpublicpower.org/debunk-council-resolution

Despite its inaccuracies, Council approved that resolution almost unanimously (Council Member Cynthia Harrison notably voted against it). 

When I wrote about that resolution previously, I reacted primarily to the deception of it. I was offended by the effort to mislead residents. Our community has quietly accepted this as a new norm in our local politics and I find it upsetting. The people currently in power understand that, with enough money, any message (true or false) can be spread far and wide. Deceptive campaigns are now the preferred method of “winning.” Since 2018, the worst of these campaigns have relied on dark money and surrogates to spread them. 

This year, in their resolution opposing Prop E, City Council took the bold step of using public resources to directly advocate and promote a deceptive campaign. The City attorney reviewed and approved it. The resolution was a clear violation of state law.

Enforcement of many rules and regulations is complaint-driven. For example, City Council has very clear rules and ethics, but the body regulates itself. Only an elected member of City Council can report a violation of rules or ethics. This self-regulating process has effectively prevented any challenge to misconduct the last four years. The unanimous Council has voted together and turned a blind eye to protect each other.

Ann Arbor City Council can not protect each other when they violate state campaign finance laws. The state allows anyone to report a violation and submit evidence.

Earlier this month, I had hoped that someone else might take on the chore of filing a complaint about Council’s violation of state law. I do not believe that anyone has, so I recently submitted complaints myself. Regardless of what ultimately happens with Proposal E, we will have a new Mayor in November. I am hopeful about Yousef Rabhi’s ability to restore integrity and accountability in our City government.

Below is what I submitted to the state.


ALLEGATIONS

Section 169.257(1) of the MCFA was violated when the public body of Ann Arbor City Council used “personnel, office space, computer hardware or software… or other public resources” to make a contribution to a campaign when it added Resolution 26-1684 to the agenda of the October 5, 2026 meeting of Ann Arbor City Council. 

In Compilers notes, the MCFA states clearly that “It is the policy of this state that a public body shall maintain strict neutrality in each election and that a public body or a person acting on behalf of a public body shall not attempt to influence the outcome of an election held in the state. If there is a perceived ambiguity in the interpretation of section 57, that section shall be construed to best effectuate the policy of strict neutrality by a public body in an election.”

Resolution 26-1684 was added to the City’s Legistar online agenda platform as item DC-4 with the title “Resolution Encouraging Ann Arbor Voters To Vote “No” on Proposal E.” It stated in part:

RESOLVED, That the City Council directs the City Attorney, at the appropriate time, to challenge the legality of Proposal E including but not limited to its revisionary effect on the City Charter.

RESOLVED, That the Ann Arbor City Council encourages voters to vote “no” on Proposal E.

https://a2gov.legistar.com/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=8259216&GUID=80182030-6DA1-4373-A66C-5A859D34B9D6

Version: 1

In adding Resolution 26-1684 to the City Council agenda, sponsors Mayor Christopher Taylor, and Council Members Dharma Akmon, Erica Briggs, and Chris Watson did intend for the public body to use City resources to influence the outcome of an election. (Note: Version 2 of Resolution 26-1684 changed the title, removing the reference to voting “no” and also removed the resolved clause directing residents to vote “no.”)

Discussion of Resolution 26-1684 generated 35 minutes of television broadcast and YouTube recording of the public body expressing opposition to Proposal E. This content was filmed, broadcast, and hosted using public resources on the City Television Network (CTN). Mayor Christopher Taylor and Council Members Lisa Disch, Cynthia Harrison, Chris Watson, Jon Mallek, Ayesha Ghazi Edwin, Travis Radina, Jen Eyer, Jenn Cornell, and Erica Briggs all participated in and contributed to this discussion. All members of City Council apart from member Cynthia Harrison voted to approve Resolution 26-1684.

City Council Meeting 10/5/26 time stamp 1:55:57
https://www.youtube.com/live/LyJoUmJrO6U?t=6957

After the inappropriate use of public resources to create the agenda item in opposition to Proposal E and broadcast 35 minutes of public discussion in opposition to Proposal E, the Resolution was referenced in a mass mailer in opposition to Proposal E. That mailer included remarks from Ann Arbor City Council Members Travis Radina, Ayesha Ghazi Edwin, and Erica Briggs. 

There is evidence of coordination between Ann Arbor City Council Member Erica Briggs and the campaign committee (“Ann Arbor Responsible Energy Coalition”), with likely intent to use this Resolution 26-1684 in the mass mailing. 

Additionally, Section 169.257 (2) of the MCFA was violated insofar as the official communication of the public body occurred fewer than 60 days before the election scheduled to decide Proposal E (November 3, 2026). 

Ann Arbor City Council did, in fact, “use public funds or resources for a communication by means of radio, television, mass mailing” in order to reference a local ballot question and “target the relevant electorate where the local ballot question appears on the ballot.”