Public commenters at the December 15, 2025 Council meeting spoke on a topic that was not on the agenda: our local law enforcement cooperating with federal ICE agents. In November, ICE agents detained a woman in Ann Arbor — when the woman needed to use the bathroom, the agents contacted the Ann Arbor police, who offered local facilities. According to MLive, County deputies helped the woman use a bathroom in the City’s Justice Center. Witnesses filmed federal agents escorting the woman out of the building and that recording was shared with the local organization Movement for Immigrant Rights Action (MIRA). At the meeting of City Council, members of MIRA raised alarm about what happened.
You can read the MLive article about what happened here:
https://www.mlive.com/news/ann-arbor/2025/12/group-speaks-out-against-ann-arbor-letting-detained-immigrant-use-city-restroom.html
I have seen this incident framed as a question of compassion and kindness toward the woman being detained. I think it’s important to clarify: our local law enforcement was asked and agreed to assist federal ICE agents, who were specifically trying to avoid use of a public bathroom in a public space. In a public space, those agents would have encountered many more witnesses and potential resistance (I hope) from bystanders. The incident does not illustrate sensitivity to a woman who needed to use the bathroom. When federal ICE agents were allowed into a City building and local deputies escorted the woman to the bathroom, our community helped the agents maintain custody of someone they had detained.
Our community has set a very troubling precedent: if federal agents are detaining people in the City of Ann Arbor, they now have reason to expect that local law enforcement will allow them into City buildings to help them maintain custody of the people they detain.
In the current climate of lawlessness at the federal level, I believe we need to consider the consequences of local policy and be strategic in our choices. Resistance means creating obstacles. We should do everything we can, legally, to make it more difficult for ICE agents to operate in the City of Ann Arbor. This week, activists from MIRA pointed to the example of Chicago, which has implemented policy to protect local residents and restrict access to City facilities and City resources.
The City of Chicago website explains their policies here:
https://www.chicago.gov/city/en/depts/mayor/supp_info/protecting-chicago.html
MLive reported this week that “City Administrator Milton Dohoney said the city does not have a policy baring anyone or any groups from city facilities” and quoted one City leader, Council Member Dharma Akmon: “While I understand and take seriously the anxiety that our community is experiencing as a result of the actions of the federal government, I fully support allowing the detained woman to use our restroom.”
I hope that other City leaders will listen to the concerns raised by public commenters this week. Every choice makes a difference and Ann Arbor can do better.
Below is a petition from Movement for Immigrant Rights Action, demanding that federal immigration officers be banned from Ann Arbor City facilities:
https://www.change.org/p/make-ann-arbor-s-city-facilities-off-limits-to-ice